New York (212) 679-1330

Video Blogs

When a Medical Emergency Is Mistaken for Impairment

Posted by Valery Cobo Castro | Nov 19, 2026 | 0 Comments

A New Jersey case now before an appellate court raises difficult questions about how police respond when a person's behavior could indicate either impairment or a medical emergency.
The case involves Cheryl Rhines, who struck a guardrail in 2017 while experiencing a stroke. According to reporting by the New Jersey Monitor, the responding state trooper interpreted Rhines' condition as possible intoxication and arrested her. Rhines' side argued that signs of a stroke were present and that the delay in medical care caused serious harm. The state argued that the trooper should receive immunity for her actions.
A jury awarded damages, and the state is now asking an appellate panel to overturn the verdict, order a new trial, or reduce the damages. Rhines' attorney urged the panel to uphold the verdict. As of November 17, 2026, the appellate court has not issued its decision.
The case puts two important concerns into focus: officers may have to make decisions quickly in uncertain situations, and people experiencing a medical crisis need timely care. The appeal raises questions about how courts weigh an officer's judgment, training, and response when deciding whether immunity applies and whether a verdict should stand.
 
Steven Goldstein's perspective:

There is a reason this case went to trial and did not settle.  Both sides have valid arguments.  Police receive basic medical training but are not sufficiently trained in recognizing the difference between certain medical ailments or intoxication, or even drug use.  The officer made the wrong call.  The case really focuses on whether the office was negligent on that call.  The jury felt yes.  Another jury may say no.  Situations like this will arise again as many other ailments and symptom,s may mimick the effects of alcohol.
 
The appellate panel's eventual ruling may clarify how these issues are considered in this case. Until then, the arguments offer an opportunity to reflect on the legal and human stakes when a roadside encounter becomes a medical emergency.
 
 
This article discusses a pending case for general informational purposes. It is not legal advice.

About the Author

Comments

There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

CONTACT US TODAY

Goldstein & Handwerker, LLP, is committed to answering your questions about Personal Injury, Criminal Defense, and DUI/DWI law issues in New York and New Jersey.

We’ll gladly discuss your case with you at your convenience. Contact us today to schedule an appointment.

Menu